[Teachers]
should recognize that the linguistic form a student brings to school is
intimately connected with loved one’s community, and personal identity. To
suggest that this form is “wrong” or, even worse, ignorant, is to suggest that
something is wrong with the student and his or her family. (p.33)
The Ebonics
debate raises some important concerns and questions regarding linguistics in
school and the classroom. Should student know Standard English? If they don’t how
can it be incorporated into the classroom without making it the main focus? If
a student is never taught Standard English will they be able to be successful?
In her
quote, Delpit states that a student's dialect is connected to their personality
and family background. If teachers competently disregard that it is completely disregarding
the child as a human being. At the same time she emphasizes the importance of
knowing Standard English. "It is equally important to understand that
students who do not have access to the politically popular dialect form in this
country are less likely to succeed economically than their peers who do"
(33).
I think it
is important for students to learn Standard English. We did not make the rules
on what is standard and what is not, but someone else did. As a society we are
under the impression that people who can speak proper English are more
intelligent and I don’t think that is going to change soon. I am not saying I
agree with this philosophy I am just saying that is how the United States is.
As teachers it would be our job to give students the opportunity to learn Standard
English. If the students choose not to take advantage of the opportunity and
the teacher tried their best to teach them there is nothing else that can be
done.
On the
other hand there are a lot of intelligent people in this country that do not
speak proper English. A lot of my science professors are from different countries
and speak with a heavy accent and are not always grammatically correct. They
still managed to be successful and earn their PhD and work at JCU. It really depends
in the area you want to work in. Many scientists come to America to do research
and excel with knowing hardly any English.